Imagine receiving a monthly marketing report filled with encouraging numbers. More impressions. More clicks. More followers. Sales attributed to advertising.
Then you look at the business account and ask: what have we actually gained after paying for it all?
That question sits at the centre of my concern about marketing today. Business owners can believe they are buying commercial progress while their suppliers believe they have fulfilled the contract by delivering activity.
AI makes this distinction more important. It can help produce convincing proposals, polished content and detailed reports quickly. But the ability to produce those things does not establish the ability to make sound decisions for a business.
I want owners to feel able to ask harder questions before committing their budget.
What are you actually buying?
A business may need an excellent videographer, copywriter, social media manager or advertising specialist. These are valuable skills, and a clearly defined assignment can be money well spent.
The problem begins when a specialist service is presented—or understood—as a complete growth strategy, with nobody responsible for connecting the work to the wider business.
An agency might deliver every promised post while the company continues targeting the wrong customers. Advertising might generate enquiries that the sales team cannot convert. A promotion might increase orders while leaving too little margin to cover the cost of acquiring them.
Someone needs to understand how these parts work together.
Marketing encompasses decisions about the product, price, distribution, customer experience and promotion. The Chartered Institute of Marketing’s marketing mix reflects that breadth. A content calendar covers only a portion of it.
Before recommending channels or campaigns, a marketer should investigate the customer, the offer, the competition and the economics of the business.
Smaller businesses have less room for expensive mistakes
Large organisations can employ specialists across research, customer insight, pricing, brand, analytics and delivery. That does not make them immune to waste, but it gives them more capacity to question recommendations and coordinate decisions.
A smaller company may rely on one employee or an external agency. The owner is also running the business and may have little time to evaluate unfamiliar marketing claims.
That creates a difficult buying decision: how do you judge expertise you do not have yourself?
You do not need to become a marketing expert before hiring one. You need enough clarity to understand what you are buying, why it has been recommended and how you will judge whether it is helping.
A limited budget calls for focused decisions. It should not mean proceeding without a strategy.
AI can make weak advice look convincing
Used well, AI can help marketers analyse information, explore ideas and produce work efficiently.
My concern is that it can also make weak advice look more complete and authoritative than it is.
A lengthy plan may still rest on assumptions nobody has checked. Professional-looking content may say nothing distinctive about the business. A confident recommendation may have little connection to what customers need.
The responsibility remains with the person making the recommendation.
Who checked the evidence? Why is this approach appropriate? What alternatives were considered? What would cause the team to change its mind?
These questions matter more than whether someone uses AI.
The same principle applies to marketing terminology. SWOT analysis, the marketing mix and ideas about differentiation can help structure thinking. Reciting them proves little. The test is whether someone can apply sound principles to your business and explain the decisions they produce.
Sales are only part of the calculation
Consider a simplified example.
A campaign generates £10,000 in genuinely additional sales. After product costs and other variable costs of fulfilling those orders, £4,000 remains before marketing costs.
Advertising costs £3,000. The associated agency fee is £1,500.
The business has spent £4,500 to generate £4,000 of contribution. It is £500 short before fixed overheads.
A report celebrating the £10,000 sales figure without explaining those costs gives the owner an incomplete picture.
Even the sales figure needs scrutiny. A platform may attribute purchases to advertising when some customers would have bought anyway.
An early loss can be a deliberate investment. A business might expect repeat purchases to make customer acquisition worthwhile over time. But that requires an agreed payback period, enough cash to support it and evidence behind the assumptions.
Future customer value should not become a convenient explanation for disappointing results today.
Ask for evidence you can assess
An agency’s ability to win clients tells you little about whether its work benefits them.
Before appointing a supplier, ask for a relevant example that explains the starting position, the full budget, the work delivered and the outcome. Ask what failed, what changed and what the supplier cannot confidently attribute to its own work.
Then make the proposal for your business equally clear:
- Objective: What business outcome is the work intended to support?
- Reasoning: Why this audience, offer and approach?
- Responsibility: Who sets the strategy, and who performs the work?
- Cost: What is included, and what requires additional spending?
- Measurement: What will be tracked, against which starting point?
- Review: When will decisions be made to continue, adjust or stop?
- Ownership: Who controls the advertising accounts, data and finished assets?
A defined initial engagement can help both sides establish whether they work well together. Its review date should reflect the task, rather than impose an arbitrary deadline for guaranteed profit.
Brand development, a product launch and a direct sales campaign need different measures and timelines. Each still needs a clear purpose and a credible way to assess progress.
Accountability belongs on both sides
Agencies need to be honest about their expertise, scope and limitations. They should explain results clearly, including disappointing results, and make recommendations the client can understand.
Business owners also have responsibilities. Marketers need accurate information about margins, customers and sales. They need timely decisions and a business capable of delivering what its campaigns promise.
Marketing cannot compensate indefinitely for a weak product, poor service or neglected enquiries. Nor can a supplier guarantee every commercial outcome.
What both sides can demand is disciplined work: clear objectives, tested assumptions, transparent costs and decisions informed by evidence.
I believe that is how standards improve. Better practical training, clearer proposals and greater scrutiny of results would serve business owners and capable marketers alike.
That scrutiny should apply to my own work as much as anyone else’s.
Before buying your next campaign, ask: what will this change in my business, how will we know, and what will we do if it doesn’t?
Elvijs Plugis is the founder and CEO of Sigulp. His expertise spans business strategy, strategic marketing, communications, partnerships and commercial development. Through Sigulp, he helps organisations connect strategy with practical delivery across marketing, PR and media, partnership development, events, advisory, commercial growth, and digital and AI discovery.
He also serves on the English Chamber Orchestra’s International Advisory Board, is a member of the Conservative Foreign & Commonwealth Council (CFCC), and is Vice Chair of the Parliamentary Society for Arts, Fashion and Sports.
